New York Times reviewer Claudia La Rocco complements Fish Eye, noting:

This production gets a lot right, beginning with the actors’ fully realized takes on their characters and continuing through much of the script’s witty back-and-forths.

Full review here at NYTimes.com.  Will Fulton at NYTheater.com applauds the production:

Colt Coeur has assembled an extremely talented group of artists for Fish Eye. They have created a show that is confidently nuanced, if somewhat comfortably familiar. They are certainly a company worth keeping on one’s radar and hopefully they will use this fantastic momentum to pursue work in the future that is more formally ambitious so as to match the talent of the people making it.

Full review here at NYTheater.com.